YOU can tell a lot from the equipment level manufacturers include on their entry-level versions.
It’s all too easy to drive a high-specification model, but such cars are often dripping with optional extras and bear little resemblance to the modest bread-and-butter machines that start a range.
That’s why it was good to get my hands on the runt of the new Vauxhall Insignia family – a 138bhp entry-level 1.8i Exclusiv five-door hatch.
It’s part of a make or break 40 model line-up for trouble-hit Vauxhall. This car has to be a sales success and help drag the UK wing of the General Motors giant back from the brink.
Under the bonnet is a surprisingly smooth 138bhp 1.8 litre multi-valve petrol engine – not the most fashionable power plant in an age where the turbodiesel is king.
I can’t quite get to grips with its exterior style. It’s an odd mixture of dynamic and bland. From some angles it looks fresh and modern with interesting reverse curves and body sculpting – but from head on its proportionally over-small grille and hamster-like flared wings make me think of First Minister Alex Salmond every time I see it.
There is also full climate control, rather lifeless power steering, an alarm and immobiliser, multi-function steering wheel, cruise control electric front windows and door mirrors, split and fold rear seat and a powerful and easy to use RDS radio and CD system with excellent sound quality.
There’s an unexpected feeling of quality inside. The dash is a masterpiece of design and assembly. It’s easy on the eye, intelligently laid out and has switchgear that feels good and positive. At night the dials are perfectly illuminated and the car’s main and dipped beams are powerful with great range and excellent verge coverage.
I liked the firm seats. The cloth covers should be hard wearing and although this is the cheapest Insignia I was pleased to see there is some electric adjustment built in for height. The steering column adjusts manually for rake and height and helps make the Insignia an easy car to get comfortable with before driving away.
Passengers liked the rear seats and the space they were allocated, but complained about feeling a little claustrophobic because of restricted head room. Like them, I found the car’s high waistline and small back window difficult to see out of with body structure restricting the driver’s backward views and making parking a real nightmare. At least the tailgate glass is fitted with a wiper.
If, like me, you use your door mirrors a lot you might find the design irritating. They are an example of style over function and rob the driver of a decent view. They need to be bigger and oblong, not stylishly triangular!
Insignias are likely to find their way into hard working business roles. Here there’s little to fault. The boot is big – 520 litres of space with a firm, flat floor. Fold the rear seats flat, it takes just seconds, and the hatch turns into a van with 1463 litres – that’s 15 litres more than on the Mondeo hatch although the Ford does offer eight more litres when the rear seats are in use.
If you were not told, you’d be hard pressed to single the Exclusiv as the cheapest Insignia. It’s exceptionally well turned out, comfortable, well appointed and quiet and relaxed on the road.
I like Vauxhall’s answer to expensive alloys. Although you can specify alloys for £425 the standard Exclusiv wheel is a clever ‘Structure’ wheel. It’s metal but designed in such a neat way that the plastic wheel trim covers all of the under structure and gives a very realistic impression of a smart spoked alloy. It’s a good-looking and cheap answer and worked well with my test car’s soft-riding 17-inch Michelin Primacy 225/55 section covers with a commonsense high profile.
On test this “everyman workhorse” gave me an easy 35mpg average in mixed driving and 38mpg on a long run to Oban. It should be frugal to service with work needed only every 20,000 miles.
It’s not as sharp or involving to drive as the Mondeo – but I found the Insignia more relaxing and satisfying.
Rating: 8/10
FINAL THOUGHT: Vauxhall has an excellent car in the Insignia – though it might regret dropping the much-loved Vectra tag. It’s big, comfortable and very well constructed with a beautifully trimmed interior and dash. The 1.8i petrol Exclusiv is a fine, if unexciting, machine but a better buy is the 130bhp two-litre CDTi turbodiesel Exclusiv at £17,615 with its much improved pulling power and a potential to average 48mpg.
Vauxhall Insignia Exclusiv 1.8i petrol five-door
Price: £16,640