IT’S disappointing when I get a car to test that is not at the top of the game compared to the rest of the range.
That’s what happened when a 1.3 TDCi turbodiesel Ford Ka turned up for the motorsnorth treatment – the most expensive version in the five-model family and the only one offering diesel.
To make this comfortably trimmed £11,195 Zetec model pay for itself you would have to be involved in some abnormal driving with huge annual mileages – or simply love oil-burning engines to the exclusion of common sense.
Why? Because the gutsy little Fiat-sourced TDCi will simply not pay its way in day-to-day use, despite its amazing average consumption of 67.3mpg, especially at the scandalously high cost of diesel fuel in the UK.
If you bought a Zetec with the superbly smooth 1.2 litre 69bhp petrol engine it would cost you £800 less, still return an average 55.4mpg, be just as quick, cost no more to insure or road tax and, crucially, be much smoother and quieter to live with.
Load-carrying ability is modest – and disappointingly restricted. The boot hatch is narrow and the loading sill awkwardly high. It makes lifting heavy items into the boot a chore and blunts its family holdall appeal. Once you get into the boot there’s a reasonable 224 litres of space and with the 50/50 split rear seat backs folded down the load area grows to 747 litres – but because the seat bench is fixed it means there’s an irritating lip in the loading floor.
The noise also blunted the audio output of the fine radio/CD system fitted as standard and controlled from the steering wheel.
Just why anyone would want to equip their Ka with the 195/45-section Continental covers on the good-looking 16-alloys fitted to my example beats me – they undermine the ride quality and deliver a deafening roar over anything but a billiard-smooth surface.
Ka’s standard wheel size is 14-inch with 65-section tyres – stick close to these and the ride comfort and noise will improve dramatically.
Instrumentation is modern and bright, but a bit low rent and plasticky. I also found the switchgear rather confusing with backlighting on certain of the centrally-grouped push-button switches too dull to stand out for quick reference at night. It would have been better too if the warning lights for the clever Quickscreen, the heated rear screen and the front and rear fog lamps had been built into the switches. Along with brighter backlit lamps it would have helped them stand out at night when you need to switch them off. What Ford has opted for is a series of warning icons that light up in the main instrument binnacle – lights I found hard to relate to whatever switch I’d just been fumbling for at night. The same poor switch identification applies to the fine radio/CD controls and is only eased by the fact that the Zetec has some radio function on the steering wheel.
Where the Ka scores highly is on seating comfort. They don’t look particularly sumptuous but the front seats offer excellent support and even in the back there’s good comfort.
Driving the car is brilliant. The electric power steering is direct and the five-speed gearbox light and easy to use. The gear lever is mounted on a pod hung off the bottom of the central console that makes it easy to reach.
The car has average oddment storage but visibility is good, though at night the dipped beam on the standard self-levelling headlamps is poor.
Twin airbags are standard and side airbags are available for a bargain £150. Pity ESP is a £300 option, but at least if you do order it you get handy hill-start launch and Brake Assist.
The good-value Zetec trim is also available with the 1.2i petrol engine at a better-value £10,395. This top trim level gives you front fogs, privacy glass, Quickclear front screen and 15-inch alloys with 50-section tyres – my diesel test car’s hard-riding 16-inchers with 45-section were a £200 option.
New Ka is a good supermini – but opt for petrol.
Rating: 6.5/10
FINAL THOUGHT: If the test car had been a 1.2 petrol Ka it would have earned a much higher rating mark than 6.5/10 – diesel and a car of this size simply does not make good sense. That’s a pity because the three-door design is clever and petrol pricing is keen. Best buy? The 1.2i Style at £9195.
Ford Ka 1.3 Zetec TDCi
Price: £11,195